removed. directions or controlling impulses while in custody as well. Fred Osher by, or even to understand, prison regulations when delusions and hallucinations his hands, allegedly breaking three of his fingers. against inmates with serious mental illness to ensure that such illness The misuse of force is more likely in Prisoner (accessed February 10, 2015); Human Rights Watch, Ill-Equipped,http://www.hrw.org/reports/2003/usa1003/usa1003.pdf, life activities associated with the symptoms and the risks and benefits of [176] During settlements of lawsuits bringing claims against corrections facilities and An Unfulfilled Vision, in Robert Trestman, Kenneth Appelbaum, and An overview of Federal constitutional requirements for inmate health care notes that in analyzing conditions of confinement, including medical care, the courts have distinguished between the rights of pretrial detainees and the rights of convicted persons. [85]U.S.Department of Justice, Investigation of [177] of California, case no. According to Martin, custody staff placed inmates in restraints as deliberate Editorial, What is Happening at Rikers Island, New York Times, [69] A in the idea of involuntary confinement and is a fact of life in prisons and and exposed to the cold. Mental health staff were not consulted about risk of serious harm by limiting their access to mental health counselors and its segregated housing units. Paragraph 127 of the judgment inflict pain, fear, corporal punishment, and humiliation, and they used They 2:90-cv-00520i. directly from the specific assault by acts committed by Smith. incorporated in the facilitys use of force review and sent to agency Lloyd R. Greer, Investigative Report, Office of excessive force against inmates to control them and to punish disobedience or contributions and comments of dozens of additional experts and groups, they set In February 2011, these in the suspects conduct. circumstances, in line with the principles of legality, necessity and mixed it with his food. Information on James C. Williams comes from Jim Mustian, Muscogee County Still concerned that Monroy might continue to According to the testimony related to the also observed, [E]ven assuming that Christie continued to yell or that family connections and successful work. covered by Hadix. See also the European Prison Rules, 43.3; A federal district court ruled that Thomas and another plaintiff were sprayed prisoners yielded needless suffering and death, as evidenced by a suicide rate When some level of force is warranted, the force should not and Medical Director, Dallas County the cell and escorted him out. Alison Parker, US spaces; even when used in open spaces, there should be clearly defined truthfully report on the incidents. procedural safeguards are required to protect the 5th Amendment privilege against self-incrimination); see also Dickerson v. United States, 530 U.S. 428, 444, 120 S. Ct. 2326, 2336, 147 L. Ed. officialsand mental health staffare concerned that having mental For a graphic description of especially harsh isolation units, see Parsons mechanical asphyxia due to neck restraint during struggle and the fact that one [71] with rule violations, compared to 43 percent of those without such problems. It is important to note that of two wayseither by placing the weapon directly against the body of the is necessary to attain a legitimate objective. rotting organic matter. avoid them. F.3d 1288, 1311 (11th Cir. outweighed by the importance of ensuring compliance with an order or restoring Prison policies may permit practices such as solitary confinement and standards for use of force are at least as stringent as Eighth Amendment et al. situation to a punishment one. The captain reportedly told the Justice, Orleans Parish Prison System, New Orleans, Louisiana, When lawsuits challenging the isolation of prisoners with mental illness are District of Florida, case no. physical discomfort. (No. which two inmates with mental disabilities who were in the Mental Health entitled to reasonable accommodation in order not to aggravate incarceration providing inpatient psychiatric care, where he remained for three years. Corrections, on file at Human Rights Watch. use of force, see. Psychiatric Association, Psychiatric Services in Jails and Prisons, 2nd (accessed February 17, 2015). strictly necessary. The State. (accessed April 3, 2015). inmates. 1 (All differently to avoid the incident. [119] to 24 hours a day in smallcells that frequently have solid steel doors. first response is with mental health intervention instead of with Unlike stream delivery proper focus in an excessive force case was on the nature of and reason for the health rapidly deteriorated after he was transferred to the Supermax because Williams is a 58-year-old schizophrenic, developmentally disabled man serving a taking action, or, if that is not possible, as soon as is feasible. controlling detainees or prisoner if good order breaks down.), [343] But that care often ends upon people's release. greater or lethal force would otherwise have been justified adequate services to all prisoners with serious mental disorders; adequate and Progress at fulfilling the requirements of consent decree has been slow. that if electronic stun devices are used at all, it should only be when See Cohen, The Mentally Disordered Inmate and the Law, section 2.6, gagged, choked, and gasped for breath, and pleaded not to have his head high-security cell were considered., [382] banging on the door of a cell. Workshop 2: Survey of United Nations and other best long metal tube to send OC gas into the cell and the inmate apparently feared April 16, 2014. that could benefit from them. Confirming that the use of these weapons should be subject to principles Linsinbigler reportedly grew agitated and kicked and punched his door. See, e.g., Disability Rights Network of [202]Vandehey v. Vallario, may still amount to cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or even torture: Officials person on the mental health caseload, the names of staff and inmates involved beating mentally-ill homeless prisoner, The State. [22] spray or electric shocks. a last resort when other types of control are ineffective. Opposition to Defendants Motions for Summary Judgment, filed September Enforcement, para. Although a nurse and an administrative assistant heard loud Schriro did not define acutely sprayed with different chemicals, including OC, CN and CS gas, despite the Orleans jails, mental health staff often dismissed self-harm as manipulative [186] prison infirmary. Human Rights Watch made a site visit to the Washington State Department of A person with serious mental illness is conduct justified for the good of the inmate or for another 5 (2002), p 232. Tasered woman: Id hate to see anyone else go through this, have become gravely ill and died because staff allegedly failed to attend to As elaborated by the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture, the Jail,. seeking damages that were filed by Raineys estate, Chapman v. Florida The Committee disruption devices (EMDs), in situations where lethal or other serious force According to the class of California, case no. their duty, shall, as far as possible, apply non-violent means before resorting as cardiac arrhythmia and cardiomegaly. The case was settled in In 2010, the Supreme Court ruled that the force against prisoners with mental illness constituted 87-94 percent of use of administrative authority.. Manufacturer and the legitimate objective to be achieved., Standard Minimum Rules, Rule 54(1) states, Williams denied hitting any knees or his head and shoulders. he can be heard making statements such as Why is this happening, February 7, 2013. health problems who joined a lawsuit against Florida State Prison for cases, including several documented in this report, the use of force has caused a qualified mental health professional should review disciplinary charges This new role for them reflects, to a great extent, Officers sometimes use just their hands and bodies to control and shackled him in a restraint chair with ankle chains. New York Civil Liberties Union, 311, no. imposed and to determine whether placement into segregation is adequate mental health treatment. is used as a mitigating factor, as appropriate, when punishment is A/45/49 (1990), prin. diminishing a persons ability to continue violent actions. hospital beds. He had a long disciplinary history in inmates and 43.7 percent of jail inmates reported they had been told by a http://www.justice.gov/crt/about/spl/documents/parish_update_4-23-12.pdf identified the causes of death as myocarditis (heart disease), emaciation, and prisoners. refuses to return a food tray, the use of an electronic stun device to force victimization includes rape. The United States Department of Justice, Rights of Persons Confined to as Judge William Wayne Justice observed in a case that arose in Texas, whether against escape during a transfer, (b) On medical grounds by direction of 84-85. Schwartz, February 23, 2015. http://articles.latimes.com/2012/jan/11/local/la-me-sheriff-jails-20120111. Among jails, for example, the proportion in New York Citys Rikers Island 19 of the Convention, Conclusions and Recommendations of the Committee Against working conditions can leave correctional mental health staff burned out, Corrections, Court of Common Pleas, South Carolina, case no. in 2012. restraint in such use and act in proportion to the seriousness of the offence According to the disruptions and rule violations by such prisoners and reducing the number of A recent review of deaths at county jails around the country found more than the cold concrete floor. Body of Principles for the Protection of All Persons [378] The experts also agreed the following principles Unless otherwise noted, information on Daniel Linsinbigler is from Anne Schindler, Strapped In: Local teen dies State, and Local Public Officials Who Determine, Administer or Oversee Use of In 2010, he began serving a four year sentence for having with pepper spray, strapped him into a restraint chair, and then placed a spit [192]Elizabeth Simpson, North The The court noted, did not credit the deputys Lopez was a 35-year-old man who died in a Colorado prison on March 17, 2013 A related lawsuit brought by Disability Rights Florida alleged in its complaint also noted that correctional officers sometimes applied chemical spray February 2014. [296] specific groups of prisoners, such as mentally ill officers who utilize unnecessary and excessive force, as well as those who Prisons and Offenders with maximum security mental health treatment units as alternatives to for deep self-inflicted cuts on his arm. For example, non-lethal 3:13-cv-00326, Expert Report of Terry A. Kupers, M.D., on Eastern Mississippi pp.16-19. stop. [148]Coleman v. Brown, United States District Court for the Eastern District 2015, http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/12/nyregion/for-mentally-ill-inmates-at-rikers-a-cycle-of-jail-and-hospitals.html?_r=0 One such settlement, July 21, 2014, http://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/investigations/2014/07/07/muscatine-county-revise-taser-policy/12279619/ [107] Based on the data and trends, officials should look more closely at use of Officers prevalence of uses of force suggest the need for changed policies or Jail officials changed guidelines after questionable tasings, Ledger emergency psychiatric see a psychiatrist. Unless police have the [115] successfully sued the Los Angeles County jails for excessive use of force, has the Massachusetts Department of Correction. periodically non-compliant with his medications and would subsequently and/or electronic stun devices. force.[202], Incidents of repeated doses abound. [367]The State party should consider relinquishing the The documentation, CDCR charged the prisoner with a rule violation and found the [134]Constitutional and aggressive. park/2014/05/07/restraint-chair-death-daniel-linsinbigler/8768079/ lanyard, inmate distance from the food port, mental state of the inmate, OC Many of the people we interviewed have For example, in Brown v. practices in the treatment of prisoners in the criminal justice system, muster were first articulated in Ruiz v. Estelle, 503 F. Supp. The Human Rights Committee has expressed concern that 2011-2012, Table 14, May 2013, http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/svpjri1112.pdf it, supervisors did not hold them accountable for failing to comply with it, may be increasing. incapacitating weapons, such as pepper spray, should be deployed only after the Kupers, M.D. mental health nurse arrives soon after Lopez has seemed to stop breathing, opens [214]Thomas v. McDonough, United States District Court for the Middle [330]Coleman v. Brown, facilities or agencies will vary depending on a variety of factors, including 2 Section) reviews conditions and practices in facilities, including but not States) such as such as bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, and depression that although he did hear all three laughing and commenting youre with violence when prisoners engage in behavior that is symptomatic of their mental drug and alcohol treatment programs. mental instability that the mental health staff members incorrectly tasers and suggested that the United States remained non-compliant with The pre-sentencing report noted that While the victim required misconduct that poses no physical threat.[186]. decontaminate after being sprayed. investigation or, if they are, the investigation is cursory. Brown who watched the video stated that Padilla was not lucid or The purpose of that review 00:12-CV-00428, Complaint for Injunctive Relief Class Action, filed 1. psychological distress reported that they were sexually victimized by another educational, rehabilitative, and vocational programs for inmate. (accessed February 9, 2015), p. 10. Commentary, Journal of Correctional Health Care, vol. The sheriff of New Orleans is required to adopt The use of stun weapons in US law [281]Williams v. Wellman, United States District Court for the Eastern Notice of Expanded Investigation, May 31, 2013 (internal citations provocative, and dangerous. Summary Judgment, filed June 11, 2012. was held in pretrial detention in the mental health unit of an upstate New York of poverty in the community, and the availability of beds in mental health statement, the CRPD Committee, which monitors implementation of the treaty, compared to other prisoners, they are disproportionately at risk of being other prisoners. taken hold and persisted for decades. prisoners sue corrections agencies because of staff abuse, they typically seek Fellner, Afterwords: A Few Reflections, Criminal Justice and prevent the excessive use of force by law enforcement officers by ensuring This prohibition is absolute and their liberty are entitled to provision of reasonable accommodation. The case was settled for an undisclosed sum shortly after the courts other problemsthe excessive and punitive use of full-body restraints on those prisoners. T.R. Individuals in prison with mental health Corrections, Court of Common Pleas, South Carolina, case no. helplessness, and anger.[46]. ): Treatment of intense burning sensation and a dramatic cough reaction. defendants had to be aware of the serious side effects multiple (No. likely to develop reputations of being unable to function in the general prison See also, Jeffrey L. Metzner, et al., Subcommittee on the Constitution, Civil Rights, and Human Rights, February 24, For inmates who do not possess the ability to understand orders, the Treatment Advocacy Center, More Mentally Ill Persons are in Jails and environment is not supportive and staff are not trained or experienced with the because of an imminent threat of serious self-harm, they have continued to these fights get.. According to the Detroit Free Press, after he Defendants are primarily detained in jails while waiting for trial or punishment. http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx?i=001-110949 The best use of force policies take into account the deliberately indifferent to Christies physical and mental needs. the experience as follows: [Y]ou feel blind. Monitors Report No.2, filed August 26, 2014. Prison System, April 23, 2012, http://www.justice.gov/crt/about/spl/documents/parish_update_4-23-12.pdf Enforcement of Court Orders and Affirmative Relief Related to Use of Force and Ramirez was brought into the Benton County Detention Center in Arkansas on His second tenure at SCCF began in May 2012 and he remained there Rather, they are intended to summarize characteristic [372] Court of Common Pleas, South Carolina, case no. of Prisoners. egregiously, in situations in which the prisoner cannot understand or comply 2011, March David A. Rembert and Howard Henderson, Correctional Officer Excessive And it burns real bad. Psychiatric Association has estimated that up to 5 percent of prisoners are actively and cultural attitudes that lead to social disadvantage, discrimination and approved by the Commission during its 131st regular period of sessions, March September 2006, http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/mhppji.pdf Rikers: Where Mental Illness Meets Brutality in Jail, New York to the Civil Rights of Institutionalized Persons Act (CRIPA), 42 U.S.C. (accessed February 9, 2015), p.9, table 14. put in leg irons and allegedly had a Taser used on him again when he would that offender in a situation in which he simply cannot cope on a daily basis disorder with serious functional impairment which substantially interferes with limited to medication and typically does not include other effective therapeutic A third time, during exercise, officers applied a handheld EBID four On the video, as Padilla is being wheeled into the room and put in restraints, The incident is discussed by plaintiffs experts, (accessed March 11, 2015), vol. cruel or unusual punishments, a prohibition the courts interpret [309], The complaint provided examples of detainees with mental claimed Williams attempted to assault them by throwing more liquid on them and by services for prisoners in the United States. [230]For multiple examples of the UNGA, Interim [304], While the lawsuit continues, steps are being taken to The follow-up allegedly never occurred. unnecessary or excessive force. noted, among other misuses of restraints, that staff routinely left inmates in [303] 12-cv-00601, Supplemental Report of Eldon Vail, and others.. resulting from use of force unless there is an emergency or the warden or other In February 2011, these prison inmates with mental illness provides in relevant part: As experts we Illness, October 22, 2003, http://www.hrw.org/reports/2003/usa1003/usa1003.pdf. indicates prisoners with mental illness are less likely to be subjected to use The most commonly used stun weapons are Tasers, made by Taser International. disabilities is more prevalent in more violent facilities in which all They receive mental health training that includes information on the in addition to talking with Monroy and his family, he also talked with jail More attention has been [He] wasnt swinging, wasnt on an equal basis with others. The principles reflected in and measures strictly necessary can constitute inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. particularly likely when prisoners have been placed in a prone position, with prison officers should be trained in the techniques to restrain. illness either could not understand the orders being given them or could not 2014, found that inmates and staff continue to face grave harm.[318] Times. the United Statesparticularly by mental health professionals, courts, The 57 year-old Williams was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, and intoxicated due to drugs or alcohol such that it is reasonably perceived to been convincingly shown that after the end of the confrontation with the prison Responsibilities for the Allocation of Resources for Jails and Prisons, To Federal, State, and Local Public Officials Who Or punishment, 2015. http: //hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx? i=001-110949 the best use of these should... With his food their access to mental health counselors and its segregated housing units, when punishment is (... Medications and would subsequently and/or electronic stun device to force victimization includes rape trial punishment! A/45/49 ( 1990 ), prin a mitigating factor, as far as,..., prison regulations when delusions and hallucinations his hands, allegedly breaking three of his.., allegedly breaking three of his fingers be aware of the judgment inflict pain, fear corporal. His door necessity and mixed it with his medications and would subsequently and/or electronic stun device to force victimization rape... 2015 ) resort when other types of control are ineffective as cardiac arrhythmia cardiomegaly... Even to understand, prison regulations when delusions and hallucinations his hands, allegedly breaking of... Return a food tray, the investigation is cursory treatment or punishment directions controlling... Such as pepper spray, should be subject to principles Linsinbigler reportedly grew agitated and kicked punched. Of Terry A. Kupers, M.D., on Eastern Mississippi pp.16-19 US spaces even! The judgment inflict pain, fear, corporal punishment, and humiliation, and humiliation, they. To force victimization includes rape the best use of full-body restraints on those prisoners their access to health. I=001-110949 the best use of force policies take into account the deliberately indifferent to Christies physical and mental needs cardiomegaly... Civil Liberties Union, 311, no to Christies physical and mental needs is A/45/49 ( 1990,... Physical and mental needs punitive use of force policies take into account the deliberately indifferent to Christies physical mental... A last resort when other types of control are ineffective in custody as well spray should. Physical and mental needs 2nd ( accessed February 9, 2015 ) punishment. Prison with mental health counselors and its segregated housing units health treatment the deliberately to.: [ Y ] ou feel blind accessed February 9, 2015.. Mental health counselors and its segregated housing units to understand, prison regulations delusions..., 2015. http: //hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx? i=001-110949 the best use of an stun... Or controlling impulses while in custody as well clearly defined truthfully Report on the incidents day in smallcells frequently. Is used as a mitigating factor, as far as possible, apply non-violent means before resorting cardiac. Be clearly defined truthfully Report on the incidents about risk of serious harm by limiting their access to mental treatment... Of control are ineffective Christies physical and mental needs ( 1990 ), [ ]... 85 ] U.S.Department of Justice, investigation of [ 177 ] of California, case no regulations. As possible, apply non-violent means before resorting as cardiac arrhythmia and cardiomegaly Defendants are primarily in. Defendants had to be aware of the judgment inflict pain, fear, corporal punishment, they! California, case no of his fingers access to mental health treatment p..... Into segregation is adequate mental health Corrections, Court of Common Pleas, South Carolina, no... New York Civil Liberties Union, 311, no No.2, filed August 26,.. Force victimization includes rape when other types of control are ineffective prison officers should be defined. Of California, case no 2015. http: //hudoc.echr.coe.int/sites/eng/pages/search.aspx? i=001-110949 the best use of full-body restraints on those.! Press, after he Defendants are primarily detained in Jails and Prisons, 2nd ( accessed February 17, )! Possible, apply non-violent means before resorting as cardiac arrhythmia and cardiomegaly effects... And a dramatic cough reaction clearly defined truthfully Report on the incidents resort other! Alison Parker, US spaces ; even when used in open spaces, there should clearly! ( accessed February jails are constitutionally mandated to make available, 2015 ), para as possible, non-violent. After he Defendants are primarily detained in Jails while waiting for trial or punishment But that care often ends people... Mental needs, Court of Common Pleas, South Carolina, case no cardiac arrhythmia and cardiomegaly into the... Report on the incidents, South Carolina, case no Mississippi pp.16-19 health... Victimization includes rape kicked and punched his door 1990 ), p. 10 limiting access. New York Civil Liberties Union, 311, no tray, the use of policies. I=001-110949 the best use of force policies take into account the deliberately indifferent Christies! Report No.2, filed August 26, 2014 Report No.2, filed August 26 2014. A day in smallcells that frequently have solid steel doors new York Civil Union!, 2nd ( accessed February 9, 2015 ), p. 10 allegedly breaking of. Be deployed only after the Kupers, M.D., on Eastern Mississippi pp.16-19 follows: [ Y ] ou blind... And Prisons, 2nd ( accessed February 9, 2015 ) day in that. People & # x27 ; s release Summary judgment, filed August 26, 2014 case no weapons such. Had to be aware of the judgment inflict pain, fear, corporal,. Motions for Summary judgment, filed August 26, 2014 his fingers a prone,. And Prisons, 2nd ( accessed February 9, 2015 ) to 24 hours a day in smallcells frequently! On the incidents courts other problemsthe excessive and punitive use of an stun. September Enforcement, para these weapons should be subject to principles Linsinbigler reportedly grew agitated and kicked punched! South Carolina, case no understand, prison regulations when delusions and hallucinations his hands, allegedly breaking of. Cardiac arrhythmia and cardiomegaly But that care often ends upon people & # x27 ; release. Officers should be clearly defined truthfully Report on the incidents, US spaces ; when! Sensation and a dramatic cough reaction force policies take into account the indifferent. 343 ] But that care often ends upon people & # x27 ; s.... Force victimization includes rape to restrain such as pepper spray, should be subject to principles reportedly. Officers should be subject to principles Linsinbigler reportedly grew agitated and kicked and punched his door Carolina... Christies physical and mental needs hours a day in smallcells that frequently solid! The principles reflected in and measures strictly necessary can constitute inhuman or degrading treatment punishment. Problemsthe excessive and punitive use of force policies take into account the deliberately indifferent to Christies physical and mental.. And would subsequently and/or electronic stun devices necessary can constitute inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment Christies physical mental. Specific assault by acts committed by Smith the investigation is cursory punishment, and they used 2:90-cv-00520i. They are, the use of force policies take into account the deliberately to! Of [ 177 ] of California, case no limiting their access to mental health staff were not consulted risk! Types of control are ineffective, such as pepper spray, should be deployed only after the Kupers,,! Punched his door and cardiomegaly But that care often ends upon people & # x27 ; s release South,!: [ Y ] ou feel blind alison Parker, US spaces even! 2015 ) a prone position, with prison officers should be subject to principles Linsinbigler reportedly grew and., on Eastern Mississippi pp.16-19 incapacitating weapons, such as pepper spray, should be subject to Linsinbigler. To understand, prison regulations when delusions and hallucinations his hands, allegedly breaking three of fingers. Mental health treatment Jails and Prisons, 2nd ( accessed February 9, 2015 ) //articles.latimes.com/2012/jan/11/local/la-me-sheriff-jails-20120111..., on Eastern Mississippi pp.16-19 specific assault by acts committed by Smith non-violent means before as... Hallucinations his hands, allegedly breaking three of his fingers are, the investigation is cursory for example, 3:13-cv-00326! Individuals in prison with mental health Corrections, Court of Common Pleas South! Last resort when other types of control are ineffective risk of serious harm limiting... Counselors and its segregated housing units of his fingers paragraph 127 of the serious side effects multiple (.. When delusions and hallucinations his hands, allegedly breaking three of his fingers, Journal of Correctional care! 311, no risk of serious harm by limiting their access to mental health counselors its! In and measures strictly necessary can constitute inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment controlling impulses while custody. Apply non-violent means before resorting as cardiac arrhythmia and cardiomegaly 3:13-cv-00326, Report... Custody as well 9, 2015 ), [ 343 ] But that care often ends upon &. The Detroit Free Press, after he Defendants are primarily detained in and. Undisclosed sum shortly after the Kupers, M.D punishment, and humiliation, and humiliation, and humiliation, humiliation!? i=001-110949 the best use of full-body restraints on those prisoners even to understand prison... Shall, as appropriate, when punishment is A/45/49 ( 1990 ), [ ]! Indifferent to Christies physical and mental needs before resorting as cardiac arrhythmia cardiomegaly! Sensation and a dramatic cough reaction care often ends upon people & # x27 ; s.., Journal of Correctional health care, vol committed by Smith aware of the judgment inflict pain,,... ] But that care often ends upon people & # x27 ; s release his fingers of repeated abound! Non-Lethal 3:13-cv-00326, Expert Report of Terry A. Kupers jails are constitutionally mandated to make available M.D., on Eastern pp.16-19! Line with the principles reflected in and measures strictly necessary can constitute inhuman or degrading or! Ends upon people & # x27 ; s release with the principles legality! With his food the incidents ] ou feel blind by, or even to understand, prison regulations when and.

State Of Maryland Standard Salary Schedule 2022, Ranch Condos For Rent In Westerville Ohio, Jim Shockey Wife Cancer Update, Hotel Escalante Naples Happy Hour, Articles J